Skip to content 
The $399 Domain Name: An SEO Relic or a Golden Ticket?
When we launched Coderby.com, we were concerned about “how to choose a domain name?”. Those days we were choosing between coderfy.online and coderfymiami.com. The other day, an email landed in our inbox. It was a straightforward pitch:
“Hello, We own the domain name FloridaAppDevelopment.com, & we are looking to sell this. The domain is available for $399 only. Would you be interested…?”
It’s a tempting offer on the surface. The domain perfectly describes a service and a location—a combination that, a decade ago, would have been an SEO goldmine. At the same time, we found a shorter, more modern alternative, floridaappdev.com, available for just about $17.
This situation is the perfect case study for a question we always get: How much does a domain name really matter for SEO today? Let’s break it down.
Old School SEO: The Keyword-Stuffing Era
There was a time when search engine algorithms were much simpler. They relied heavily on explicit keywords to determine what a webpage was about. If you wanted to rank for “Florida app development,” owning FloridaAppDevelopment.com was a massive advantage.
These were called Exact Match Domains (EMDs). They worked by sending a powerful, direct signal to search engines like Google: “This website is 100% about this specific topic.” For years, businesses that snagged these EMDs often enjoyed top rankings with less effort than their competitors. The seller of our $399 domain is counting on this old-school thinking.
The Google Evolution: From Keywords to User Experience
Here’s the reality check: The internet of 2025 is a different world. Google’s algorithms are now incredibly sophisticated. They’ve evolved to think more like a human, prioritizing factors that indicate quality, trust, and a good user experience.
While keywords still matter, the weight of an Exact Match Domain has been significantly reduced. Google realized that just because a domain name matched a search query didn’t mean the website offered the best information or service. Spammers and low-quality sites were exploiting this loophole.
Today, Google’s focus has shifted to:
- High-Quality Content: Is your content well-researched, well-written, and genuinely helpful to the user?
- User Experience (UX): Is your site fast, mobile-friendly, and easy to navigate?
- Brand Authority: Is your business a recognized, trusted name in its field? Do other reputable sites link to you?
A keyword-stuffed domain addresses none of these critical modern ranking factors.
The Showdown: FloridaAppDevelopment.com vs. FloridaAppDev.com
Let’s compare our two options head-to-head in the context of modern SEO and branding.
FloridaAppDevelopment.com ($399)
- Pros: Highly descriptive, leaves no doubt about the business focus.
- Cons:
- Expensive: The price is over 20 times higher.
- Long and Clunky: It’s a mouthful to say and a pain to type. Imagine putting that on a business card or telling someone over the phone.
- Looks Spammy: Overly long, hyphenated, or keyword-stuffed domains can look less professional and more like a site built purely for SEO, hurting user trust.
floridaappdev.com (~$17)
- Pros:
- Cost-Effective: The price is unbeatable.
- Short & Memorable: It’s catchy, easy to type, and easy to remember.
- Brandable: “Florida App Dev” sounds like a modern tech brand. It’s clean, professional, and versatile for logos and marketing.
- Cons: It’s not the exact search term, but as we’ve discussed, that’s no longer a major drawback.
The clear winner for a modern business is floridaappdev.com. It’s cheaper, better for branding, and more user-friendly—all things that Google and your customers will appreciate more than a string of keywords.
What Really Matters for SEO in 2025: Our Advice on How to choose a domain name
So, do we need that $399 domain? Absolutely not.
Instead of overspending on a domain name, here’s where you should invest your time and money actually to improve your SEO:
- Choose a Brandable Domain: Pick a short, unique, and memorable name. Your brand name is more important than a generic keyword phrase. Think
Google,Amazon,Coderby—none of these are keyword-stuffed. - Invest in High-Quality Content: Start a blog, create detailed service pages, and publish case studies. Answer the questions your potential customers are asking. This is the #1 way to build authority and rank for your target keywords.
- Optimize Your Website’s Technical Foundation: Ensure your site is lightning-fast, secure (HTTPS), and perfectly optimized for mobile devices.
- Focus on Building a Brand: Create a great logo, be active on social media, and encourage customer reviews. A strong brand builds trust, which in turn boosts SEO.
Your domain name is your website’s foundation, but it’s the house you build on it that truly matters. Don’t fall for the old myth that an expensive, keyword-rich domain is a shortcut to success. Build a great brand, provide real value, and you’ll earn your rankings the right way.
The Coderby Approach: Investing in Content, Not Just Keywords
This exact scenario highlights our core philosophy at Coderby. Let’s say we wanted to attract clients in Miami. The old-school approach would be to buy a domain like miamiwebsitedevelopment.com.
But what would we do with it? Start a whole new website from scratch? That means building up its authority, content, and backlinks from zero—a slow and expensive process. Redirect it to our main site? Google has confirmed this provides little to no SEO benefit.
Here’s the more brilliant, Coderby-approved strategy: We would invest that same money and effort directly into our existing Coderby.com blog and portfolio.
Instead of buying a new domain, we could create a powerhouse piece of content like:
A Detailed Case Study: “How We Helped a Miami Startup Increase Sales by 300% with a New E-commerce Site.”
An Ultimate Guide: “The Complete Guide to Web Development Costs and Services in Miami.”
A Stunning Portfolio Page: Showcasing our best work with other Florida-based businesses.
A single, high-quality blog post on our established, authoritative Coderby.com domain will do more for attracting clients in Miami than an empty, keyword-stuffed domain ever could. We’re leveraging our existing brand trust and SEO power to target a new market, which is a far more efficient and effective strategy. Value is built with content, not by collecting domains.
Buying Your First Domain?
Get instant feedback on your domain idea below.
Key Principles for a Great Domain
- Prioritize Brand Over Keywords: Focus on a unique, memorable name. A strong brand is more valuable than a generic, keyword-stuffed domain.
- Keep It Short & Simple: Avoid hyphens, numbers, and complicated words. If you have to spell it out, it’s too complex.
- Stick with .com: It’s the most trusted and recognized extension. Always make it your first choice if available.
- Think Long-Term: Choose a name that allows your business to grow and evolve without needing to rebrand.
